CollectorRecovery
Active Investigations

Active Cases & Rewards

CollectorRecovery.org maintains open investigations into stolen trading card cases. Rewards are offered for information leading to recovery or prosecution. Anonymous tips are welcome.

1
Active Case
$10,000
Max Reward
6,451
Items Stolen

Open Investigations

Active InvestigationCR-2026-001
October 2026

October 2026 PSA/FedEx Theft

A large-scale theft of PSA-graded trading cards occurred during FedEx transit in October 2026. PSA published an official list of 6,451 stolen inventory items on October 23, 2026. The investigation is ongoing. No suspect information is being published at this time.

Confirmed Facts

  • 6,451 PSA-graded items confirmed stolen
  • Theft occurred during FedEx transit
  • PSA published official stolen inventory list on October 23, 2026
  • Cards retain their original PSA certification numbers
  • Stolen slabs may be offered for resale — check before you buy
Reward: $5,000–$10,000
PSA Stolen List (PDF)PSA AnnouncementSubmit a Tip

Additional Cases Coming Soon

CollectorRecovery.org is expanding its case registry. Additional investigations will be listed here as they are opened.

Pending

Case Under Review

An additional case is currently under review for inclusion in the registry. Details will be published once verified.

Pending

Case Under Review

An additional case is currently under review for inclusion in the registry. Details will be published once verified.

Reward Program

CollectorRecovery.org offers independent rewards for information that directly leads to the recovery of stolen cards or the arrest and conviction of those responsible.

$5,000
Recovery Reward

For information that directly leads to the verified physical recovery of stolen PSA-graded cards listed in the CollectorRecovery.org registry.

$10,000
Arrest & Conviction Reward

For information that directly leads to the arrest and criminal conviction of an individual responsible for a theft listed in our registry.

Who Qualifies

  • Any individual with direct knowledge of the whereabouts of stolen cards or the identity of those responsible
  • Anonymous tips are accepted and eligible — you do not need to identify yourself to submit
  • Tips must be submitted through CollectorRecovery.org or directly to Tips@CollectorRecovery.org
  • The tip must be the proximate cause of the recovery or conviction — not information already known to law enforcement
  • Reward is paid per case, not per card — one reward per qualifying tip per case
  • CollectorRecovery.org reserves the right to verify recovery or conviction before issuing payment

How to Claim

  1. 1Submit your tip through the Submit a Tip form or email Tips@CollectorRecovery.org directly
  2. 2Include contact information if you wish to be considered for the reward — anonymous tips are welcome but cannot be paid out without contact details
  3. 3Our team will follow up if your tip leads to a qualifying outcome
  4. 4Reward payment is issued after verified recovery or confirmed conviction

Important Notes

CollectorRecovery.org is an independent organization and is not affiliated with PSA, FedEx, or any law enforcement agency. Rewards are offered independently and are not guaranteed by any third party. Submitting false information may constitute a crime. CollectorRecovery.org cooperates with law enforcement and may share tip information with investigators.

Have information about a case?

Submit a tip — anonymous tips are welcome and may qualify for the reward.

Submit a Tip

Buying a graded card?

Check the cert number against our stolen card registry before you buy.

Search the Registry